Skip to Content

Why does Dumbledore ask Snape after all this time?

The Harry Potter series is filled with many complex and fascinating characters, but perhaps none are more interesting than the enigmatic Severus Snape. Snape is a character full of contradictions: he’s a skilled potions master, a member of the Death Eaters, and, perhaps most importantly, a double agent working for Dumbledore. He’s also one of the more controversial characters in the series, with many fans arguing over whether he’s ultimately a hero or a villain.

One of the most memorable moments in the entire Harry Potter series comes towards the end of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, when Harry is finally confronting Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest. In that moment, Harry learns the full extent of Snape’s loyalty to Lily Potter, and how that loyalty played a crucial role in the ultimate defeat of Voldemort.

But what is perhaps even more memorable than Snape’s story itself is a single line of dialogue that has since become a meme: “After all this time?” “Always.” In this blog post, we’ll explore the significance of this line, and what it says about Dumbledore, Snape, and their complicated relationship.

A Brief Summary of Snape’s Story

Before we dive into the meaning behind Dumbledore’s question, it’s worth providing a brief summary of Snape’s story up to that point. Severus Snape is a complex character who, throughout the course of the series, is revealed to have a complex past and a complicated role in the fight against Voldemort.

As a young boy, Snape was bullied at school, and his only friend was a fellow student named Lily Evans. After graduating from Hogwarts, Snape joined the Death Eaters, a group of wizards who supported Voldemort and his quest for power. However, Snape’s loyalty was always complicated. He continued to harbor feelings for Lily, even after she married James Potter, and ultimately became a double agent working for Dumbledore.

Throughout the series, Snape is often portrayed as cruel and vindictive, particularly towards Harry Potter. It’s not until the end of the series that we learn the full extent of Snape’s loyalty to Dumbledore and his love for Lily.

Dumbledore’s Question

In the climactic scene of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Harry finally confronts Voldemort. As Harry is approaching the Forbidden Forest, he thinks about all the people who have died fighting Voldemort, including his parents, Sirius Black, and Dumbledore.

At that moment, Harry discovers the truth about Snape’s past. He learns that Snape had been in love with Lily Potter, and that his loyalty to her was so strong that he agreed to become a double agent for Dumbledore in order to protect her son. In fact, Snape had been working for Dumbledore all along, secretly passing information to him and ultimately sacrificing his own life to ensure that Voldemort could be defeated.

It’s at this point that Harry utters the famous line: “After all this time?” “Always.” This line reveals the depth of Snape’s love for Lily, and how that love motivated him throughout his life. But it also says a great deal about Dumbledore and his relationship with Snape.

The Significance of “Always”

The word “always” is a powerful one. It suggests a sense of permanence and immutability. In the context of Snape’s story, it suggests that his love for Lily was a constant presence in his life, guiding his decisions and motivating him to do the right thing, even when it was difficult.

But “always” also has significant implications for Dumbledore. By asking Snape whether he still loved Lily “after all this time,” Dumbledore is acknowledging the depth of Snape’s love, and perhaps even expressing some sympathy for it. He’s also, in a way, apologizing for the way he treated Snape over the years. Throughout the series, Dumbledore is often portrayed as manipulative and dismissive of Snape, using him to achieve his own ends without ever truly trusting him.

But by asking Snape this question, Dumbledore is validating Snape’s feelings and acknowledging the sacrifices he made out of love. In a way, he’s telling Snape that his loyalty was worth it, and that his life had meaning and purpose.


The line “After all this time?” “Always” has become one of the most iconic moments in the entire Harry Potter series. It speaks to the complexity of Snape’s character, and the depth of his love for Lily. But it also suggests that there was more to Dumbledore and Snape’s relationship than we previously realized.

Ultimately, “always” is a testament to the power of love, and the way that it can motivate people to do extraordinary things. It’s a reminder that even the most complex and contradictory characters can have a profound impact on the world around them. And it’s a testament to the enduring power of the Harry Potter series, which continues to captivate readers and inspire new generations of fans.


Why did Dumbledore ask Snape?

Dumbledore is a key figure in the wizarding world, known for his wisdom, power, and extraordinary confidence. He has an extensive knowledge about magic, and his influence reaches far and wide. His most significant undertaking in the world of magic is his fight against evil. As a protector of the innocent, Dumbledore is determined to stop the forces of darkness that threaten the world of magic, no matter the consequences. This is where Snape comes in.

During the events of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, we see Dumbledore approaching Snape, who is working as a double agent for Voldemort at the time. Dumbledore’s original plan is to have Snape kill him when the moment is right, although Snape is initially reluctant to do so. However, during their confrontation, the true reason behind Dumbledore’s request becomes clear. As it turns out, Dumbledore asks Snape of this because he wants to spare Draco from a wounded soul and the wrath of the Dark Lord himself, Voldemort.

Draco Malfoy, one of the main protagonists in the series, has long been affiliated with the Dark Lord and his activities. Draco’s father, Lucius Malfoy, is one of Voldemort’s most devoted followers, and his family has a long history of involvement with the Death Eaters. Despite his family’s dedication to the cause, Draco is not as evil as his family. He is not a killer by nature and has reservations about the mission given to him by Voldemort.

Dumbledore, aware of Draco’s internal conflict, realizes the young wizard is destined to face a terrible fate. If he continues down the path his family and Voldemort have set for him, he will inevitably become corrupted and broken, ultimately leading to his downfall. Instead of allowing that to happen, Dumbledore asks Snape to kill him and give Draco the chance to turn away from the darkness. Dumbledore’s sacrifice ultimately secures Draco’s safety, leaving him and his family alive at the end of the series.

Dumbledore’S request to Snape was not just a simple request for assistance. It was a decision made after careful thought and consultation with his trusted ally. He knew that his sacrifice would not only stop Voldemort but also allow Draco to escape a fate that would have destroyed him. His wise actions saved Draco and secured the future safety of the wizarding world.

What was Snape’s secret message?

In the book series Harry Potter, Severus Snape, a professor at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, is portrayed as a stern and often antagonistic character towards the protagonist, Harry Potter. However, as the series progresses, we learn that Snape harbors a deep and complex history, including a secret message that he sends to Harry after his death. The question then arises: what was the message that Snape was trying to convey, and what was its significance in the grander scheme of things?

During the series, it is heavily implied that Snape had a complicated and tumultuous past relationship with Harry’s mother, Lily Evans, as well as with his father, James Potter. It is revealed that Snape was deeply in love with Lily from an early age, but that their friendship was ultimately destroyed when he joined the Death Eaters, a group of dark wizards that were aligned with Voldemort. This led to Lily breaking off all contact with Snape and ultimately marrying James Potter. However, despite their estranged relationship, it is clear that Snape continued to harbor feelings for Lily throughout his life.

In the final book of the series, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, we learn that Snape’s love for Lily is the key to understanding his secret message. After Snape is killed by the dark wizard Voldemort, Harry discovers that Snape had been protecting him all along, not because he cared for him personally, but rather because he had promised Lily that he would keep her son safe. To convey this message to Harry, Snape leaves behind a series of memories that Harry must view in order to understand the full extent of Snape’s love and sacrifice.

The final memory that Snape leaves for Harry is a particularly poignant one. In it, we see Snape speaking with Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts, and revealing his true feelings for Lily. He says, “According to Victorian flower language, asphodel is a type of lily meaning ‘my regrets follow you to the grave’ and wormwood means ‘absence’ and also typically symbolizes bitter sorrow.” Combining these two meanings, we can infer that Snape is saying, “I bitterly regret Lily’s death.”

This message is significant in a number of ways. Firstly, it reveals the depth of Snape’s love for Lily, and his regret and sorrow over her death. It also shows how much he was willing to sacrifice for Harry, despite his personal feelings towards him. Additionally, it highlights the importance of communication and how hidden meanings can have a significant impact on our understanding of a situation.

Snape’S secret message is a powerful and emotional moment in the Harry Potter series. It reveals the complex and multi-faceted nature of Snape’s character, and his unwavering loyalty to Lily and her memory. It also serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of love, sacrifice, and communication, and the impact that these things can have on our lives and our relationships.